In 1959, William Russell and Rex Burch introduced the 3R principle (Replacement, Reduction and Refinement) in their book ‘The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique’.
- Replacement: to replace the use of laboratory animals by alternative methods to animal testing. Examples are the use of in vitro methods (such as human cell- and tissue cultures) and in silico models (via computer simulations).
- Reduction: to reduce the number of laboratory animals. An example of reduction is the accurate calculation of the number of laboratory animals required for a scientific study. However, it is important to note that the number should be sufficiently high to obtain statistically reliable results. Another example includes the sharing of laboratory animals, so that certain organs can be used for one study and the carcass and/or the remaining organs for another study or for educational purposes.
- Refinement: to refine experiments by minimizing the inflicted pain and distress to the laboratory animals as much as possible and maximizing their well-being. Examples to reduce the stress level in laboratory animals include group housing of social animals, sufficient cage enrichment, respect for the natural day/night cycle of the laboratory animal ...
Sometimes a fourth R for "Responsibility" is added referring to the "Culture of Care" philosophy in laboratories to which each scientist should contribute. According to this philosophy, scientists and lab technicians are committed to work in an ethical and correct way, obtaining as much scientific progress as possible while minimizing animal suffering.
In Belgium, the European Directive 2010/63 concerning the protection of animals used for scientific purposes has been transposed into the Royal Decree concerning the protection of experimental animals (29 May 2013 - only available in NL and FR) . This Royal Decree is the responsibility of the Animal Welfare Departments, and is implemented at the regional level. As a result, the Flemish Region, the Brussels-Capital Region and the Walloon Region are each individually responsible for the implementation of this regulation within their respective region.
What is a laboratory animal ?
The legal definition of a laboratory animal is provided in the Law of 14 August 1986 on the protection and welfare of animals (only available in NL and FR):
- "Living cephalopods used or intended to be used in animal experiments, or those that have been bred specifically to use their organs or tissues for scientific purposes;
- living non-human vertebrates used or intended to be used in animal experiments, or those that have been bred specifically to use their organs or tissues for scientific purposes, including their independently feeding larval forms, as well as fetal forms of mammals as from the last third of their normal development;
- This definition also applies to animals used in animal experiments which are in an earlier stage of development than that referred to in the previous paragraph, if they are to remain alive beyond that stage of development and, as a result of the animal experiments carried out, are at risk of experiencing pain, suffering, distress or lasting harm after reaching that stage.”
According to this definition, all vertebrates (mammals, birds, fish, amphibians and reptiles) are included in the term 'laboratory animal'. However, this does not automatically mean that animal experiments may be performed on all vertebrates. Experiments on great apes, for example, are forbidden in Belgium. In Europe, animals may also no longer be used for testing cosmetics or for the development of tobacco products. Most invertebrates (insects, worms,...) are not included in this definition and may therefore be used for animal experiments. The use of cephalopods (squids and octopuses) is an exception to this definition, as experiments with this species are considered as animal experiments.
What is an animal experiment ?
The legal definition of an animal experiment is provided in the Law of 14 August 1986 on the protection and welfare of animals (only available in NL and FR): "any invasive or non-invasive use of an animal for experimental or other scientific purposes, of which the outcome is known or unknown, or for educational purposes, which may cause the animal as much or more pain, suffering, distress or lasting harm as the insertion of a needle applying good veterinary practice. This also includes any action of which the purpose or possible consequence is the birth or the hatching of an egg of an animal or the establishment and maintenance of a genetically modified animal species, but does not include the killing of animals for the sole purpose of using their organs or tissues.
What is the origin of the term "alternative methods"?
The term "alternative methods" is often associated with the 3R principle ("Replacement, Reduction, Refinement") and refers to ‘a method (i) that completely replaces the use of a laboratory animal, or (ii) that reduces the number of required laboratory animals in an experiment or (iii) that refines a test procedure in such a way that the inflicted pain and distress in the laboratory animal is minimalized.’
In the RE-Place project, we focus on alternative methods that are categorized as Replacement and Reduction.
What are 'alternative methods' - 'Non Animal Methods' - 'New Approach Methodologies'?
A few years ago, there was an international trend to refer to test methods that do not use vertebrates as ‘Non Animal Methods’. Similarly to 'alternative methods to animal testing', the term 'Non Animal Methods' was mainly used in the field of toxicology and in particular for regulatory applications. However, due to the rapid increase in the number of new methods in biomedical research (e.g. development of organoids), there was a need for a definition that reaches beyond the domain of (regulatory) toxicology. More recently, the abbreviation NAM is therefore increasingly defined as 'New Approach Methodologies' instead of 'Non Animal Methods'. Nevertheless, until today, the three terms are still used interchangeably. As the RE-Place project specifically also aims to collect methods from biomedical research, the term 'New Approach Methodologies' will be mainly used throughout the website.
What does in chemico mean?
In chemico research is based on the chemical and physiological properties of a certain substance/product. This information can be used, for example, to predict the activity or toxicity of certain substances/products (e.g. in the development of new medicines). A more concrete example is the ‘Direct Peptide Reactivity Assay‘(DPRA) to evaluate the potential of a component to induce skin sensitization.
What is an in silico method?
In silico methods are based upon computer simulations. By using mathematical models, the properties and behavior of certain molecules and/or components are predicted. A typical example is a '(quantitative) structure-activity relationship [(Q)SAR]' model.
What is the difference between in vivo, in vitro and ex vivo methods?
- In vivo research refers to studies on living organisms in which both animals (an animal experiment) and humans (a clinical study) can be used. The main advantage of in vivo research is that the collected information applies to the general effects on the entire organism and not just on one specific level (cell/tissue/organ).
- In vitro methods are performed in a controlled environment such as a Petri dish. A typical example are methods that involve the use liver-specific cell lines (e.g. primary human hepatocytes) to investigate the effects of future medicines.
- Ex vivo research is situated between in vivo and in vitro research. The best-known examples are methods that make use of tissue slices or organs from deceased animals (e.g. originating from slaughterhouse waste).
What does IATA mean?
When using an IATA or ‘Integrated Approach to Testing and Assessment’, a combination of different NAMs [e.g. (Q)SARs, in chemico, in vitro, ex vivo,...] is used to investigate a certain hypothesis. An example is the combination of QSAR predictions with data from in vitro research to predict the safety of certain substances or components.
What is Read-across?
In read-across, the properties of a given substance are predicted by using data from substances with similar structures.
RESOURCES ON NAMs
Databases for alternatives:
- ALTBIB - ‘Resources for Alternatives to the Use of Live Vertebrates in Biomedical Research and Testing’
- BioModels - EBI’s repository of mathematical models of biological and biomedical systems
- EURL ECVAM: DB-ALM - DataBase on Alternative Methods
- EURL ECVAM: JRC QSAR Model Database - Comprising ‘Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship’ models
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on breast cancer research
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on respiratory disease research
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on neurodegenerative disease research
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on Immuno-oncology
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on Immunogenicity Testing of Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMP)
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on Cardiovascular diseases
- EURL ECVAM: Knowledge base on Autoimmune diseases
- EURL ECVAM: TSAR - ‘Tracking System on Alternative Methods’
- FCS-free Database - A database for alternatives to the use of Free Calf Serum
- Inventory of 3Rs Knowledge Sources
- Microphysiology Systems Database
- NAT - Database on ‘Non-Animal Technologies’
- NC3Rs resources on Animal-free in vitro technologies
- Virtual Metabolic Human database
- ZEBET database on alternatives to animal experiments on the Internet
3Rs for education and training purposes:
- ASCCT Webinars provided by the ‘American Society for Cellular and Computational Toxicology’
- Altertox Academy connects international experts to provide hands-on-training in alternative methods and technologies for toxicologists
- CAAT Education program
- CAMARADES-NC3Rs Preclinical Systematic Review & Meta-analysis Facility (SyRF)
- ESTIV Course - Applied In Vitro Toxicology Training Course by ESTIV
- InterNICHE Alternatives Database - Database of alternatives in education
- NORINA - An overview of alternatives for education and training purposes
- SOT In Vitro Toxicology Lectures
- The Science Bank - Alternatives to animal use in education
- VPH institute webinars - The Virtual Physiological Human institute (VPHi) connects scientists from the life sciences, computer modeling and engineering to stimulate in silico medicine research in which the human body is studied as a whole
European 3R Grants and Prizes
- Belgian Council Laboratory Animal Science (BCLAS) 3R’s Fund in honour of René Massin
- Belgian Prices Medicine, Biomedical Sciences, Pharmacy and Veterinary Sciences via the ‘Koninklijke Academie voor Geneeskunde van België (KAGB)’
- Dutch Association for Laboratory Animal Science (DALAS) - Price for alternatives (the Netherlands)
- Willy Heumen Prize (the Netherlands)
- Hugo van Poelgeest Prize (the Netherlands)
- Tierschutzforschungspreis (Germany)
- Forschungspreis "Ersatz- und Ergänzungsmethoden zum Tierversuch" (Germany)
- Forschungspreis zur “Erforschung von Ersatz- und Ergänzungsmethoden für Tierversuche” (Germany)
- Felix-Wankel-Tierschutz-Forschungspreis (Germany)
- Ursula M. Händel-Tierschutzpreis (Germany)
- 3R prize from the Danish 3R-centre (Denmark)
- Björn Ekwall Memorial Award (Sweden)
- Norecopa 3R prize (Norway)
- EPAA 3RS awards and grants: 3Rs Student Grant, EPAA Refinement Prize (EU) and EPAA 3Rs Science Prize (EU)
International 3R Grants and Prizes
- NC3Rs International 3Rs prize (United Kingdom)
- NC3Rs Project Grants (United Kingdom)
- NC3Rs Public Engagement awards (United Kingdom)
- Egon Naef Foundation 3R Prize (Switzerland)
- Targeted Calls of the Swiss 3R Competence Centre (Switzerland)
- Refinement Grants of the Swiss 3R Competence Centre (Switzerland)
- Knowledge Transfer of the Swiss 3R Competence Centre (Switzerland)
- 3Rs Award and Young 3Rs Investigators award of the Swiss 3R Competence Centre (Switzerland)
- ALTEX Prize (Switzerland)
- Doerenkamp-Zbinden Prize (Switzerland)
- Universität Zürich 3R award (Switzerland)
- Egon Naef Foundation 3R Prize (Switzerland)
- Alternatives Research & Development Foundation (ARDF) Annual Open Grants (United States of America)
- Johns Hopkins University Grants (United States of America)
- Johns Hopkins University Awards (United States of America)
- Society of Toxicology (SOT) Awards (United States of America)
- Association for Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care International (AAALAC) Global 3Rs Awards Program (United States of America)
- International Society of Transgenic Technologies 3Rs prize (United States of America)
- Charles River Prize in Laboratory Animal Science and Medicine (United States of America)
- Canadian Association for Laboratory Animal Science (CALAS) Awards Program (Canada)
Support from animal welfare organisations
- PETA Recombinant Antibody Challenge (Germany)
- PETA Funding to Advance the Development and Use of Non-Animal Methods (Germany)
- Ärzte gegen Tierversuche, Herbert-Stiller-Förderpreis (Germany)
- Comité scientifique Pro Anima, Descroix-Vernier EthicScience Prize (France)
- Summer Studentship Award Programme of FRAME (United Kingdom)
- FRAME's Innovation Grant scheme (United Kingdom)
- Open Grants Animal Free Research (United Kingdom)
- The Humane Research Trust (United Kingdom)
- The International Animal Welfare Science Society Grants and Awards (United Kingdom)
- The International Animal Welfare Science Society Replacement, Refinement and Reduction (3Rs) Award (United Kingdom)
- The Lush Prize (United Kingdom)
- Animal Free Research Funding (United Kingdom)
- Animal Free Research Pioneer Award (United Kingdom)
- Nordic Prize for Alternatives to Animal Experiments (Denmark, Finland, Sweden)
- International Foundation for Ethical Research (IFER) (United States of America)
- BCLAS - Belgian Council for Laboratory Animal Science
- Animal Welfare service Flemish Government
- Animal Welfare service Brussels Government
- Animal Welfare service Walloon Government
- Infopunt Proefdieronderzoek
- 3Rs-Centre Utrecht Life Sciences
- 3Rs Center Czech Republic
- Austrian 3R Center by The RepRefRed Society
- Bf3R - ‘German Centre for the Protection of Laboratory Animals’
- CAAT Europe - Centre for Alternatives to Animal Testing
- CCAAM - Canadian Centre for Alternatives to Animal Methods
- Centro3R - Italian Interuniversity Center for the Promotion of the 3Rs Principles in Teaching and Research
- Danish 3R-Centre
- FICAM - ‘Finnish Centre for Alternative Methods’
- FIN3R - '3R Centre Finland'
- FC3R - 'French Centre for 3Rs'
- Francopa - ‘French platform for the development of alternative methods in animal testing’
- IC-3R’s - ‘Innovation Centre-3Rs Alternatives’
- IPAM - ‘Italian Platform on Alternative Methods’
- IZSLER - ‘Istituto Zooprofilattico Sperimentale della Lombardia e dell'Emilia Romagna’
- NA3RSC - ‘The North American 3Rs Collaborative’ in 3 languages
- NC3Rs - ‘UK National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research’
- Norecopa - ‘Norway's National Consensus Platform for the advancement of the 3Rs’
- REMA - ‘Spanish Network for the Development of Alternative Methods’
- SNP3Rs - ‘Slovak National Platform for 3Rs’
- Swedish 3Rs Centre
- Swiss 3Rs Competence Centre
Other 3R initiatives:
- ALURES - ‘Statistical EU Database on the use of animals for scientific purposes’
- AniMatch enables scientists to connect and share organs/tissues of used animals
- ARRIVE guidelines - A checklist of recommendations to improve the reporting of research involving animals
- Biograf3R - Biographics laboratory 3R for the reduction and replacement of animal testing by computational methods
- Charité 3R Toolbox provides information resources from all over the world
- COST Improve - Network of 3R Centres working to refine, harmonise and promote data, documents and 3Rs concepts to improve the quality of preclinical research
- EARA - ‘European Animal Research Association’
- EPAA - ‘European Partnership for Alternative Approaches to Animal Testing’
- EUROoCS - ‘European Organ-on-Chip Society’
- EUSAAT - ‘European Society for Alternatives to Animal Testing’
- ETPLAS - ‘Education and Training Platform for Laboratory Animal Science
- ICCVAM - ‘Interagency Coordinating Committee on the Validation of Alternative Methods’
- IIVS - ‘Institute for In Vitro Sciences’
- INVITROM - ‘International Society for In Vitro Methods’
- IVTIP - ‘In Vitro Testing Industrial Platform’
- Ncad - ‘Nationaal Comité advies dierproevenbeleid’
- NICEATM - ‘NTP Interagency Center for the Evaluation of Alternative Toxicological Methods’
- SID - ‘Stichting Informatie Dierproeven’
- Tpi.tv - A broadcasting network that aims to connect professionals who want to have a dialogue on content
- 3Rs self-assessment tools for organisations by NC3Rs